Whether you want a single type of cheese on your cheese pizza or numerous cheeses, there are plenty of places to get cheese pizza in James City County!
JCC has two fast casual pizza restaurants in New Town: Blaze Pizza and Z Pizza. Blaze Pizza offers gluten-free crust and vegan cheese. They also have multiple varieties of cheese: shredded mozzarella, ovalini mozzarella, gorgonzola, parmesan and ricotta. ZPizza also offers vegan and gluten-free options.
Restaurants
Baker’s Crust
Baker’s Crust pizzas are brought to life in a 900 degree stone deck Neapolitan pizza oven. The Bianca with fresh mozzarella, garlic, olive oil, oregano, red pepper flakes, basil would certainly satisfy cheese pizza day! There is also a classic cheese and a four cheese (quattro formaggi) on the menu.
Craft 31
This restaurant on Strawberry Plains Road offers authentic Bottoms Up thin crust pizza. Cheese pizza is part of their build their own menu, but there are also gluten-free and vegan cheese versions!
Jamestown Pie Company
Specializing in all sorts of pies, Jamestown Pie Company offers pizza pies and is a great option for cheese pizza day.
New York Deli & Pizza
With authentic New York-style pizza in Williamsburg, if you crave that specific style, New York Deli & Pizza is the place to go!
Pizzeria Marzano
With their fresh ingredients and authentic Neapolitan style pizza, Pizzeria Marzano offers a daily lunch special (1 topping personal pizza, side salad and beverage) for $6.49!
Two Sisters Pizzeria
Two Sisters Pizzeria has two locations – one on John Tyler Highway and one on Richmond Road in Toano. Either is sure to satisfy your craving for cheese pizza!
More restaurants that serve cheese pizza or flatbreads:
Daddyo’s Tavern
Francesco’s Ristorante Italiano
Guiseppe’s Italian
Maurizio's Italian Restaurant
Olde Town Pizza & Pasta
Paul’s Deli and Neighborhood Restaurant
Bonus pizza tip– Papa Murphy’s Take N’ Bake allows you to purchase quality pizzas and bake them at home in your very own oven! If you don’t feel like going out, just grab one of their pizzas on your way home to celebrate Cheese Pizza Day.
Are there any hot spots for cheese pizza that we missed?